President Obama is set to propose limits and rollbacks on health insurance premium increases this week. This is stupid policy for a lot of reasons. For starters, insurers have to pass along increases in what they pay in claims. The way to reduce those claims isn’t to cap premiums but to encourage more efficiencies in the healthcare system.
I get it that people are pissed off about paying more in premiums. But insurance companies are in business and have to make a profit. Their profits aren’t obscene — they operate on slim margins as it is.
Capping the limits will lead to consequences that Obama and his economically-retarded advisors won’t want. Insurers will have to use even more scrutiny in paying (make that denying) claims. They’ll also have to be more cautious about risks they assume, meaning they’ll tighten underwriting so that it’s more difficult to get coverage unless you’re in perfect health. Or even, where states allow them, adjust benefits accordingly — which means decreases in the amount of coverage and increased liabilities to the insured.
Judge these things by the results, not the intentions. Just as when state officials try to cap the price of any good or service, the result isn’t good for consumers — it invariably leads to a shortage. In this case, it will be a shortage of claims payments, benefits, or even available coverage for people with “routine” maladies for which underwriting otherwise wouldn’t be problematic. That’s no way to get more people covered in this country.
It’s time for the Democrats to get over their bizarre obsession with trying to micromanage our healthcare system and our health insurance sector. When are they going to do something meaningful to create an environment in which people actually want to grow their businesses and expand our economy?
The evolution of the financial crisis in the last 2 years is congealing consensus around both a more efficient regulatory structure and the corresponding institutional structure to overhaul government regulations and institutions pertaining to the financial markets. The ongoing debate is healthy and collegial and has matured from the status quo mindset of the ‘90s of an outright rejection of the need for any reforms to the acceptance of at least having to reform the Government Sponsored Enterprises (GSEs) during the Bush years.
The agony of economic reality, not merely in the last couple of years but for the foreseeable future if nothing is done, has opened up the economic establishment from the academics in Boston to the policymakers in Washington to reforming the Washington Consensus itself, unlike the necessary but not sufficient transparency reforms the International Monetary Fund (IMF) went through after the Asian Crisis about a decade ago. Then it was the IMF’s fault and the United States was perfect. Now, the United States must change, if not for the IMF, for its own sake because the health of the republic is at risk.
Senators Dodd and Shelby deserve kudos for their extraordinary sensibility, along with their colleagues on the Senate Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs for taking their sworn obligation to oversee the Fed (and its relationship with the Treasury) seriously. And so do representatives Barney Frank and Ron Paul. The Congress has acted to making financial regulatory reform happen by getting the ball rolling in the right direction in spite of the usual interest group politics in Washington to dilute any and all serious change for the better. There is room for sensible compromise among all the stakeholders, including the interest groups, but the moment to get it all done right is now, not gradually over time.
Representative Paul is correct in that the Fed is not necessary as a separate institution. It had not come into being until 1913 but the country grew rapidly as an industrial power without it, with the Fed’s star rising because of the two world wars after its founding by President Wilson and the Congress. What is indispensable is sound money and the lessons in the nearly 100 years since the Fed’s founding can ensure that that is feasible without the Fed. It can be done by the Treasury using an explicit numerical inflation targeting range written into law and changeable with the explicit consent of the Congress when circumstances warrant, but within reason.
The financial markets have also evolved considerably since the Great Crash of 1929. It is the government that needs to do the catching up. The alphabet soup of government agencies overseeing the rapidly expanding activities of U.S financial markets since FDR can all be streamlined and consolidated under the Treasury to both enforce regulations and do data collection and analysis that monetary policy needs to do its job more thoroughly. There is no reason why any financial instrument must be traded outside of exchanges in the markets and no reason why private financial institutions should not countercyclically save for a rainy day with the government in lieu of Basel. Both these legislative changes will greatly enhance the transparency of the financial markets.
The world of Obama and his Facebook presidency is technologically a far cry from the fireside chats of FDR. Since the advent of plastic, more Americans today do not need hard cash either in their wallets or jingling in their pockets. It is time for the United States to move to a more robust electronic currency and payments system to more effectively complement the financial surveillance function of the Treasury.
The consolidation of financial regulatory policy and all macroeconomic policy instruments by adding monetary policy to the current responsibilities of the Treasury for budgets, taxes and trade will enable more transparent economic policymaking and make it more accountable and time consistent through the constitutional checks and balances of the separation of powers, besides ensuring strategic coherence (which is now the job of the National Economic Council in the White House). Economic forecasts made for the purposes of monetary policy could then be made available to the public in real time for them to be debated and vetted by policymakers, academics, press and the people in a manner no different from how the Congress currently makes legislation or the Executive branch formulates and implements policies.
It may seem on the surface that such a massive consolidation of government institutions and functions can be very disruptive. The reality is that it changes none of the current routine bureaucratic operations of any of the government agencies involved. The council of regulators being considered by the Senate to be led by the Secretary of the Treasury would be a good start to begin that consolidation at the level of the decision makers to change bureaucratic processes to conform to the new legislation, without either the need to move personnel or remake facilities. The consolidation process must be subject to a timeline presented by the council to the Congress and preferably completed by December 2013, the 100th anniversary of the Federal Reserve.
The essence of reform is the legislation and the presidential stroke of a pen.
It’s not pretty. That’s for certain. But to celebrate MyWHaT’s first Pay Pal donation a cart-wheel along 8th St. was in order–yeh!!! The form should improve with every new donation.
The editor doing a very humble cart-wheel along 8th St. (Thanks A&J)
Thank you everyone for your support. It has been great!
A big question in the beginning was: “Would anyone read it?“.
In 2 months, MyWHaT has generated more than enough energy to keep it moving forward–mostly through the use of magic… but the over 6000 views, almost 200 comments and many new friends has been a key component.
It’s approaching a time when the scale of the BLOG will either need to scale down or generate some revenue for the combination of daily posting, researching and general mischief. A plan is developing that should be ready by March, but in the meantime gestures of support— comments, offers of lunch and donations through Pay Pal are really appreciated.
I will continue to do to attempt cart-wheels in appreciation (just off film).
“In creating, the only hard thing’s to begin; A grass-blade’s no easier to make than an oak.” -James Russell Lowell
Pay Pal
One question I have: Do you read MyWHaT daily, occasionally, or wait for a weekly round-up?
___
If you see something you like, please subscribe to this BLOG’s feed and also pass this link on to a friend.
In the gargantuan arm wrestling contest that has been going on between Ron Paul and the Fed, it looks like the Congressman, and with him the public, has had its hand to within a millimeter of the hot coals of inflation, with the Fed ready to cry victory. But suddenly we notice that hand has raised up and rebounded, albeit not by much. But it is the first victory for Ron Paul and the public of savers in America in a very long time.
For that victory consists in the Fed having had to raise the discount rate for the first time in three years, and by doing so, they are showing that they can no longer play the “milk the savers for all they are worth” game the Fed and the big banks have been playing for the last few years. They finally realize that it is the disposable incomes of the retired generation that create so much of the discretionary spending that kept the economy humming, and now the Fed has cut the rates to the absurd under 1% level, they now perceive that they have, in one sense, gained a Pyrrhic Victory, because in cutting rates that low, they have cut the throats of the retired savers by massacring their interest incomes, and those savers were one of the key engines of the economy. They also know that the anger of those savers is one of the key elements of the Ron Paul swathe of the Tea Party Movement, and they dread an election where anti-inflationists and transparencyists would be swept into office en masse, as will occur next November.
But Ron Paul’s constant hammering away at the Fed, and the rising voices of support, like Senators DeMint and Bunning, have finally brought such pressure to bear on the Fed that they have been forced to take a move, however minuscule, that is counter-inflationary in order to calm the roiled waters of the markets.
Just as the Fed was about to slam Dr. Paul’s hand onto the coals and give him and his supporters a good singeing, the doctor and his supporters have started to pull the fat out of the fire.
One small step backward for the Fed, one giant leap forward for Ron Paul and the savers of America.
A few points of clarification might be in order for those wondering what the fuss is all about in the contrast between the modern and the postmodern (and the amodern, which is really what we ought to be about).
The modern world view takes its perspective from the foundational works of the European Enlightenment and the Scientific Revolution. One of its characteristic features is often referred to as the Cartesian duality, or subject-object split, in which we (the subjects) enter the previously-existing objective world as blank slates who deal with reality by adapting to the facts of existence (which are God-given in the full Christian version). Many Marxists, feminists, and postmodernists see modernism as a bastion of white males in positions of political and economic superiority oblivious to the way their ideas were shaped by their times, and happy to take full advantage of their positions for their own gain.
Postmodernism takes a variety of forms and has not yet really jelled into any kind of uniform perspective; in fact, it might not ever do so, as one of its few recurrent themes has to do with the fragmentation of thinking and it local dependence on the particular power relations of different times and places. That said, a wide variety of writers trace out the way we are caught up in the play of the language games that inevitably follow from the mutual implication of subject and object. Subject and object each imply the other in the way language focuses attention selectively and filters out 99% of incoming stimuli. Concepts originate in metaphors that take their meaning from the surrounding social and historical context, and so perception and cognition are constrained by the linguistic or theoretical paradigms dominating the thoughts and behaviors of various communities. We cannot help but find ourselves drawn up into the flow of discourses that always already embody the subject-object unities representing in speaking and writing.
When we choose discourse over violence, we do so on the basis of a desire for meaning (Ricoeur, 1974), of an inescapable attraction to the beautiful (Gadamer, 1989, 1998), of a care that characterizes the human mode of being (Heidegger, 1962), of a considerateness for the human vulnerability of others and ourselves (Habermas, 1995), of an enthrallment with the fecund abundance of sexual difference (Irigaray, 1984), of the joy we experience in recognizing ourselves in each other and the universal (Hegel, 2003), of the irresistible allure of things (Harman, 2005), or of the unavoidable metaphysical necessity that propositions must take particular forms (Derrida, 1978).
All violence is ultimately the violence of the premature conclusion (Ricoeur, 1974), in which discourse is cut off by the imposition of one particularity as representative of a potentially infinite whole. This reductionism is an unjustified reduction of a universal that precludes efforts aimed at determining how well what is said might work to represent the whole transparently. Of course, all reductions of abstract ideals to particular expressions in words, numbers, or other signs are, by definition, of a limited length, and so inevitably pose the potential for being nonsensical, biased, prejudiced, and meaningless. Measures experimentally justifying reductions as meaningfully and usefully transparent are created, maintained, and reinvented via a balance of powers. In science, powers are balanced by the interrelations of theories, instruments, and data; in democracy, by the interrelations of the judicial, legislative, and executive branches of government. Just as science is continuously open to the improvements that might be effected by means of new theories, instrumentation, or data, so, too, are democratic governments continuously reshaped by new court decisions, laws, and executive orders.
An essential idea here is that all thinking takes place in signs; this is not an idea that was invented or that is owned by postmodernists. C. S. Pierce developed the implications of semiotics in his version of pragmatism, and the letters exchanged by William James and Helen Keller explored the world projected by the interrelations of signs at length. The focus on signs, signification, and the play of signifiers does not make efforts at thinking futile or invalidate the search for truth. Things come into language by asserting their independent real existence, and by being appropriated in terms of relations with things already represented in the language. For instance, trees in the forest did not arrive on the scene hallmarked “white pine,” “pin oak,” etc. Rather, names for things emerge via the metaphoric process, which frames new experiences in terms of old, and which leads to a kind of conceptual speciation event that distinguishes cultural, historical, and ecological periods from each other.
Modernists interpret the cultural relativism that emerges here as reducing all value systems to a false equality and an “anything goes” lack of standards. Unfortunately, the rejection of relativism usually entails the adoption of some form of political or religious fundamentalism in efforts aimed at restoring bellweather moral reference points. One of the primary characteristics of the current state of global crisis is our suspension in this unsustainable tension between equally dysfunctional alternatives of completely relaxed or completely rigid guides to behavior.
But the choice between fundamentalism and relativism is a false dichotomy. Science, democracy, and capitalism have succeeded as well as they have not in spite of, but because of, the social, historic, linguistic, and metaphoric factors that influence and constitute the construction of objective meaning. As Latour (1990, 1993) puts it, we have never actually been modern, so the point is not to be postmodern, but amodern. We need to appropriate new, more workable conceptual reductions from the positive results produced by the deconstruction of the history of metaphysics. Though many postmodernists see deconstruction as an end in itself, and though many modernists see reductionism as a necessary exercise of power, there are other viable ways of proceeding that remain to be explored.
The amodern path informs the trajectory of my own work, from the focus on the creation of meaning in language to meaningful measurement (Fisher, 2003a, 2003b, 2004, 2010b), and from there to the use of measurement and metrological networks in bringing human, social, and natural capital to life as part of the completion of the capitalist and democratic projects (Fisher, 2000, 2002, 2005, 2009, 2010a). Though this project will also ultimately amount to nothing more than another failed experiment, perhaps sooner than later, it has its openness to continued questioning and ongoing dialogue in its favor.
References
Derrida, J. (1978). Structure, sign and play in the discourse of the human sciences. In Writing and difference (pp. 278-93). Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Fisher, W. P., Jr. (2000). Objectivity in psychosocial measurement: What, why, how. Journal of Outcome Measurement, 4(2), 527-563 [http://www.livingcapitalmetrics.com/images/WP_Fisher_Jr_2000.pdf].
Fisher, W. P., Jr. (2003a, December). Mathematics, measurement, metaphor, metaphysics: Part I. Implications for method in postmodern science. Theory & Psychology, 13(6), 753-90.
Fisher, W. P., Jr. (2003b, December). Mathematics, measurement, metaphor, metaphysics: Part II. Accounting for Galileo’s “fateful omission.” Theory & Psychology, 13(6), 791-828.
Fisher, W. P., Jr. (2004, October). Meaning and method in the social sciences. Human Studies: A Journal for Philosophy and the Social Sciences, 27(4), 429-54.
Fisher, W. P., Jr. (2005). Daredevil barnstorming to the tipping point: New aspirations for the human sciences. Journal of Applied Measurement, 6(3), 173-9 [http://www.livingcapitalmetrics.com/images/FisherJAM05.pdf].
Fisher, W. P., Jr. (2009, November). Invariance and traceability for measures of human, social, and natural capital: Theory and application. Measurement (Elsevier), 42(9), 1278-1287.
Fisher, W. P., Jr. (2010a). Bringing human, social, and natural capital to life: Practical consequences and opportunities. Journal of Applied Measurement, 11, in press.
Fisher, W. P., Jr. (2010b). Reducible or irreducible? Mathematical reasoning and the ontological method. Journal of Applied Measurement, 11(1), 38-59.
Gadamer, H.-G. (1989). Truth and method (J. Weinsheimer & D. G. Marshall, Trans.) (Rev. ed.). New York: Crossroad (Original work published 1960).
Gadamer, H.-G. (1998). Praise of theory: Speeches and essays ( Foreword by Joel Weinsheimer, Ed.) (C. Dawson, Trans.). New Haven, Connecticut: Yale University Press.
Habermas, J. (1995). Moral consciousness and communicative action. Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press.
Harman, G. (2005). Guerrilla metaphysics: Phenomenology and the carpentry of things. Chicago: Open Court.
Hegel, G. W. F. (2003). Phenomenology of mind (J. B. Baillie, Trans.). New York: Dover (Original work published 1931).
Heidegger, M. (1962). Being and time (J. Macquarrie & E. Robinson, Trans.). New York: Harper & Row (Original work published 1927).
Irigaray, L. (1984). An ethics of sexual difference (C. Burke & G. C. Gill, Trans.). Ithaca, New York: Cornell University Press.
Latour, B. (1990). Postmodern? no, simply amodern: Steps towards an anthropology of science. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science, 21(1), 145-71.
Latour, B. (1993). We have never been modern. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press.
Ricoeur, P. (1974). Violence and language. In D. Stewart & J. Bien (Eds.), Political and social essays by Paul Ricoeur (pp. 88-101). Athens, Ohio: Ohio University Press.
Greg Mankiw defends Republican congressman who opposed the stimulus but are bragging back home about directing stimulus money to their districts. He points out that it is not logically inconsistent to both oppose government spending as a means to fight a recession, and to also direct such spending it to their constituents in the event that there is inevitably going to be stimulus.
I won’t disagree with the claim that the position is logical; once there’s definitely going to be a pie, it’s not wrong to fight for your share, and that’s important to point out. Furthermore, Mankiw admits, as will I, that he’s not familiar with the details of these supposed congressional hypocrites. I’ll go a step further though, and say that the details matter here, and without them you can’t really defend the congressmen.
For instance, when celebrating the greatness of a local stimulus project, a congressman owes the local constituents a disclaimer that if he could have things his way, he would rather this project not exist. Also, if he’s going to praise all the jobs created by it, he should probably point out that he believes the project on net is going to destroy jobs. If that’s logically consistent enough to please their constituents, then great. But to omit those points is to imply more support for the project than is accurate. Did the congressmen make those disclaimers?
Another problem I have with his defense is this metaphor of his:
Many Democratic congressmen opposed the Bush tax cuts… But once these tax cuts were passed, I bet these congressmen paid lower taxes. I bet they did not offer to hand the Treasury the extra taxes they would have owed at the previous tax rates. Would it make sense for the GOP to suggest that these Democrats were disingenuous or hypocritical? I don’t think so.
A more apt metaphor would be if Democratic congressmen who opposed the Bush tax cuts then went to their home towns and made stump speeches bragging about the jobs those tax cuts were going to create. Would it make sense for the GOP to suggest that these Democrats were disingenuous or hypocritical? I think Mankiw would agree that it would.
I usually don’t blog about profs unless I’m complaining, but Metrosexual Prof (MProf for short) is just too amusing not to write about. The first time I met him, I figured he was either a)your stereotypical gay, b) metrosexual, c)high. I went with metrosexual because it seemed to fit best. I’ve since discovered that he’s not any of the above, but the name just has a certain ring to it.
The first thing we, as a class, noticed about MProf is his ADDness….he’s literally all over the place. He’ll be saying something, then cut off to have another conversation before returning to the original point, and if you ask a question, you really just want to be like “focus, prof, focus” because he’ll interrupt you and get distracted and go off on all kinds of tangents. It’d be annoying if it weren’t so amusing.
The second thing we noticed was his complete addiction to Diet Coke. Our class is 1 hour 15 minutes long. He drinks two cans of Diet Coke every single class, without fail. The one day he forgot his backup can, he had to leave the class to go buy a Diet Pepsi, and then had to keep going back to how “some people would see Coke and Pepsi as substitutes, but those people would be wrong….” Then today he was a little late for class because he just flew in from Florida, and he was going through his bag muttering “oh no, oh no, oh no,” and we’re just like “you forgot your Diet Coke, didn’t you?” He did, and he was freaking out. His addiction is really quite amusing.
The most amazing thing about MProf is that even with his ADDness and general out-there attitude, I actually learn in that class, unlike some of my classes where the profs are really well qualified and really well focused, etc, etc. I guess the fact that he makes it fun makes it way easier to pay attention and learn. Yay for MProf!